Send us Fan Mail

On March 13, 1987, Nancy Newman — an Anchorage, Alaska mother of two, waitress, and certified public accountant — had dinner with her sister after her shift. She came home to her daughters: Melissa, age 8, and Angie, age 3. She never showed up for work again. Two days later, when family members entered the Newman home, they discovered one of the most devastating crime scenes in Anchorage history.

In this episode, host Ashley walks through the complete story of the Newman family murders: the investigation launched by the Anchorage Police Department and the FBI, the groundbreaking use of forensic hair and fiber analysis, the FBI criminal profiling that identified the killer's psychological blueprint, and the eventual arrest, trial, and conviction of Kirby Anthoney — a family member with a prior history of sexual violence against children.

This episode explores how microscopic trace evidence, behavioral profiling testimony from FBI Special Agent John Douglas, and relentless investigative work delivered justice for three victims who deserved to be seen.

Content Warning: This episode contains descriptions of homicide and sexual violence against adults and children.

Runtime: 30 minutes | True Crime | Forensic Science | FBI Profiling | Alaska

Sources:

The FBI Files, Season 1, Episode 4: "Death in Alaska"

Crimes and Consequences Podcast, Episode 239: "The Newman Family Massacre"

Kirby v. State, Alaska Court of Appeals (748 P.2d 757; also 1987 WL 1359307

Anchorage newspaper archives, 1987