It was supposed to be a twenty-five-minute flight.

Huntsville, Alabama to Atlanta, Georgia. Southern Airways Flight 242. A routine late-afternoon hop on April 4, 1977, operated by a DC-9 with 81 passengers and a crew of four. Captain Bill McKenzie had 19,380 flight hours. He had flown through the same stretch of Alabama and Georgia skies that very morning — mild turbulence, light rain, nothing unusual.

The weather had changed while he was on the ground.

Ten minutes after takeoff from Huntsville, Flight 242 flew into a thunderstorm that the onboard radar had not adequately shown them. Rain hammered the fuselage. Hail cracked the cockpit windshield. And then, in rapid succession, both engines — both of them — flamed out. A DC-9 with 85 people aboard became a glider at 17,000 feet over northern Georgia.

What followed in the next several minutes is one of the most extraordinary sequences in the history of commercial aviation. Two pilots who had no power, no real options, and diminishing altitude searching desperately for somewhere to put a jetliner down in the hills and forests of Paulding County, Georgia. Two flight attendants in their twenties — Catherine Lemoine Cooper and Sandy Purl Ward — who received no communication from the cockpit, figured out on their own that something catastrophic was happening, and prepared 81 passengers for a crash landing without being told to. A two-lane highway that appeared beneath the clouds at the last possible moment. A gas station that didn't survive the rollout. A woman named Sadie Burkhalter Hurst who looked out her front door and watched the fuselage of a passenger jet come to rest in her yard.

Twenty people walked away from Southern Airways Flight 242. Nine people on the ground did not.

In this episode of File 47: Investigative History, we open the case file.

We examine the decisions that preceded the flight — the weather briefing that didn't happen, the captain who stayed in the cockpit at Huntsville instead of going inside for an updated forecast, the dispatcher whose call to the weather service found a busy signal and stopped trying. The chain of small decisions, each one defensible in isolation, that assembled into catastrophe.

We examine the CVR record of the final minutes — what the pilots said to each other, what they said to air traffic control, and the specific exchange in which a controller mentions a small airport at Cartersville, ten miles north, that the crew acknowledges and then cannot reach.

We examine Catherine Cooper and Sandy Ward — what they did in the cabin while the cockpit was consumed by an engine restart crisis that was never going to succeed, and why the NTSB specifically commended them in a finding that most accounts of this crash have never adequately foregrounded.

And we examine the ground — the town of New Hope, Georgia, the highway, the gas station, the cars that were on that road, and the community that has gathered at the crash site every April 4th since 1978.

A companion article is available on Medium — linked in the show notes.

Subscribe to File 47: Investigative History for new episodes every week.