A 10-month-old baby disappears from her crib.

LINKS AT THE BOTTOM!

Parents are inside the house.

The front door is unlocked.
A window screen has been removed.
And the crib is empty.

No clear suspect.
No clear explanation.

On October 4, 2011, Lisa Irwin vanished from her Kansas City home. More than a decade later, the case is still unsolved — and the questions about what really happened that night have never gone away.

In this episode of Fractured Justice, we examine the timeline of Baby Lisa’s disappearance, the investigation that followed, and why this case still frustrates people who have followed it for years.

True Crime Gear Mentioned In This Episode

True Crime Notebook – Mystery Buff Journal (120 pages for tracking cases, theories, and timelines)
https://amzn.to/46UHQYX

Classic 1920s Short Brim Fedora Hat – old-school detective style accessory
https://amzn.to/3NkksNR

If you enjoy deep dives into unsolved mysteries, missing person cases, and controversial investigations, subscribe to Fractured Justice: True Crime.

Justice may be fractured… but the search for truth continues.

Support the show

Gear We Use to Record Every Episode

• Camera – DJI Osmo Pocket 3
https://amzn.to/4rkviS0

• Microphone – Shure MV6 USB
https://amzn.to/4rXhPjU

• Headphones – Shure Studio
https://amzn.to/3OP9UXw

Support the show for as little as $1 or sign up for premium content.

An 84-year-old grandmother walked into her home.

She was never seen again.

Nancy Guthrie disappeared on January 31st, 2026 leaving behind her phone, her medication, and a mystery investigators still cannot explain.

Police say they believe she was taken against her will.

But more than a month later…

there are still no arrests.

In this episode of Fractured Justice True Crime we break down the timeline of Nancy’s disappearance and explore the theories investigators must confront.

Then we travel back 36 years to Michigan to examine the haunting disappearance of Paige Renkonski.

Two women.
Two cases.
And a chilling question.

How does someone vanish without a trace?

CHAPTERS

00:00 The Hook – A Grandmother Disappears
01:10 The Night Nancy Vanished
05:30 Inside The House
09:45 Police Believe She Was Taken
14:00 The Growing Reward
17:20 Theories Investigators Consider
30:00 A Cold Case From Michigan
31:10 Paige Renkonski Disappearance
36:40 Are These Cases Connected?
41:00 Final Thoughts

Support the show

Gear We Use to Record Every Episode

• Camera – DJI Osmo Pocket 3
https://amzn.to/4rkviS0

• Microphone – Shure MV6 USB
https://amzn.to/4rXhPjU

• Headphones – Shure Studio
https://amzn.to/3OP9UXw

Support the show for as little as $1 or sign up for premium content.

An ordinary night.
A missing doorbell camera.
A phone left behind.

Nancy Guthrie vanished — and this episode examines what happened without speculation or shortcuts.

In this extended Fractured Justice investigation, we break down the full timeline, the forensic evidence, offender behavior, and the systemic imbalance that decides which cases get attention — and which are forgotten.

This is not fast true crime.
This is the kind that stays with you.

Chapters:

Introduction to the Case
Before something goes wrong, there is always a moment where everything is still normal.

The Last Normal Day
January 31st, 2026 — Nancy Guthrie’s last confirmed normal day.

Evening Routine
An ordinary family evening. No warning signs.

The Night of Disappearance
Nancy returns home. The garage door closes at 9:50 PM — the last confirmed moment she is safe.

The Silence of the Night
No disturbances, no calls, no alerts. The night passes quietly.

Early Morning Events
The doorbell camera is disconnected. Motion is detected again at 2:12 AM.

Evidence of Intent
Camera interference and pacemaker disconnection suggest deliberate action.

Morning Realization
Nancy misses her online church service. Family discovers she is missing.

The Investigation Begins
911 is called. Deputies arrive. The home becomes a crime scene.

Support the show

Gear We Use to Record Every Episode

• Camera – DJI Osmo Pocket 3
https://amzn.to/4rkviS0

• Microphone – Shure MV6 USB
https://amzn.to/4rXhPjU

• Headphones – Shure Studio
https://amzn.to/3OP9UXw

Support the show for as little as $1 or sign up for premium content.