Last week, Melissa Kegler said she was going to get her record back.

This week, the universe said, we’ll see about that.

What follows is five months of waiting for water that is somehow both too warm and too frozen, a logistical nightmare involving flights, storms, dams, and one very specific 24-hour window where everything finally (and briefly) aligns.

It is, by all accounts, the worst swim of her life.

Naturally, she does it anyway.

There’s something quietly unhinged about preparing your body for hypothermia on a biweekly basis, dragging friends and coworkers into the chaos, and then—when it finally happens—thinking, “This feels terrible. I might die. Let’s keep going.”

And yet.

Somewhere between the near-bail, the dead-man float (briefly considered, quickly abandoned), and a very well-earned post-swim pizza, Melissa figures out exactly what she’s capable of—and, more importantly, how she wants to do it next time.

Also: hypothermia. Surprisingly...fun???

Support the show

There are people who set goals.
And then there’s Melissa Kegler—who hears a mildly unhinged suggestion and thinks, yes, that seems reasonable.

In Part 1, we trace the origin story: from pool swimmer to open water wanderer, to casually knocking out the Triple Crown (Catalina, the English Channel, Manhattan… as one does). Along the way: crocodile-adjacent panic, questionable water conditions, dolphins, bioluminescence, and just enough vomiting to keep things grounded.

It’s a story about curiosity, momentum, and the dangerous power of someone asking, “Have you ever thought about…?”

Unfortunately, someone did.

And next week, it gets cold.

Support the show

Courtney's tooth fell out again. Emily's hair is orange. Sarah Beth's pit bull has a pink belly. We're off.

Somewhere in the middle of all that, we talk about Rosemary — Courtney's dear friend, gone two years this week. She spent her life helping traumatized kids and reminded us that hurt people don't just hurt people. Hurt people heal people.

Then it gets weird (weirder?). We cover:

• Why every woman should embrace being called a bitch (hint: it just means you have a backbone)
• Sarah Beth's theory that not wanting to pet her dog makes you a bad person (retracted, sort of)
• Emily's hair falling out in clumps
• How to actually like yourself (Courtney Googled it — we'll share the results)
• Clay Play™ — which is, allegedly, pottery

Plus: why your fallopians go feral around baby animals

No agenda. No plan. Three women, like eight dogs, one squirrel, and a HOT TAKE!

Warning: Contains one unsolicited dog vasectomy offer

📬 thatwasnttheplanpod@gmail.com 🌐 thatwasnttheplan.com

Just because it wasn't the plan doesn't mean it wasn't supposed to happen.

Support the show